Doug gathers some of his favorite guests for the 2nd annual Twelve Guests of Christmas, a single-elimination Leonard Maltin game battle royale!

Round Category Player Names Challenger Answer Person Eliminated
1 Obama Marc Maron 6 Brie Larson The Fifth Element Marc Maron
2 Pussy Galore Jimmy Pardo 7 Kate Micucci Cats and Dogs Jimmy Pardo
3 4-Letter Titles Alison Haislip 7 Sarah Silverman Spun Alison Haislip
4 Hay Everybody Brian Posehn 11 Scott Aukerman Seabiscuit Brian Posehn
5 X-Mas Not Christmas Riki Lindhome 7 Chris Hardwick Edward Scissorhands Riki Lindhome
6 To, Too, or Two Scott Aukerman 6 Graham Elwood Two of a Kind Scott Aukerman
7 Michael Myers Sarah Silverman -1 Brie Larson The Love Guru Brie Larson
8 Too Long for Leonard Graham Elwood 0 Kate Micucci Avatar Kate Micucci
9 War on Christmas Graham Elwood 7 Chris Hardwick War of the Roses Chris Hardwick
10 Nein, Nein, Nein Sarah Silverman 0 Samm Levine Valykrie Samm Levine
11 It’s a Punderful Life Sarah Silverman 9 Graham Elwood Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel Sarah Silverman

Place Player Movies Named
1 Graham Elwood 2
2 Sarah Silverman 2
3 Samm Levine 0
4 Chris Hardwick 0
5 Kate Micucci 0
6 Brie Larson 0
7 Scott Aukerman 0
8 Riki Lindhome 0
9 Brian Posehn 0
10 Alison Haislip 0
11 Jimmy Pardo 0
12 Marc Maron 0